Close Menu
Milligan, Beswick, Levine & Knox, LLP - Attorneys at Law
  • Confidential Consultations
  • Hablamos Español

Domestic Violence Charges in California: What Happens if the Alleged Victim Doesn’t Cooperate

Domestic Violence Charges in California: What Happens if the Alleged Victim Doesn’t Cooperate

Domestic violence cases don’t always unfold exactly how you expect. An alleged victim may call the police during a dispute or even give a statement to the police, but later decide they do not want to move forward with the charges. What does that mean for the person accused of domestic violence? Because these cases can get murky without the cooperation of the alleged victim, it’s important to plan your next steps with the help of a domestic violence defense attorney in California.

At Milligan, Beswick, Levine & Knox, LLP, we understand the nuance that these cases can carry. The way they affect interpersonal relationships, future opportunities, and current freedoms means that they must be handled carefully. Attorney James Knox devotes most of his legal practice to defending those accused of a crime, serving as a skilled litigator and committed advocate. Call our domestic violence defense law firm at 909-798-3300 to set up a consultation now.

Does California Law Allow Alleged Victims to Drop Domestic Violence Charges?

One common misconception is that domestic violence victims choose whether to drop charges against an alleged assailant. While prosecutors can absolutely take into account a victim’s preferences, a victim is not the one who presses charges. A prosecutor is the one who files charges and pursues a criminal case. Even when a victim asks for a case to be dropped, a prosecutor is not required to do so. When you work with a domestic violence defense lawyer, they’ll likely know whether a specific prosecutor is likely to drop charges at a victim’s request.

This is especially relevant in domestic violence cases, as prosecutors may believe that a victim’s request not to prosecute comes from fear, pressure, financial dependence, or family concerns.

What “Not Cooperating” Actually Means

Lack of cooperation with a criminal case can take several forms, and the extent to which someone does not cooperate may affect how your domestic violence defense attorney approaches your case. An alleged victim may:

  • Refuse to speak with the prosecutor
  • Decline to speak voluntarily in court
  • Claim not to remember what happened
  • Recant earlier statements

These situations can significantly influence what options a prosecutor has and how they may proceed.

How Prosecutors Can Build a Case Without the Alleged Victim

In some cases, a prosecutor may be able to build a case without a victim’s cooperation. Because this is case-specific, your domestic violence defense lawyer can explain what evidence the prosecutor has against you. Prosecutors may use:

  • 911 recordings
  • Body camera footage
  • Photos of injuries
  • Medical records
  • Statements made to officers
  • Text messages and voicemails
  • Testimony from third parties

What Happens if the Alleged Victim Recants Their Story

Recanting does not automatically result in dismissal. If an alleged victim gives one version of events to police and later gives a different account to law enforcement, the prosecutor may compare both statements with the other evidence available. They may claim that the original statement is more reliable or that the new statement is a result of intimidation or fear. The defense may argue that the inconsistency between the stories creates reasonable doubt.

Can the Alleged Victim Be Required to Come to Court?

While it is easier for the prosecution if the victim goes to court willingly, they can still force the victim to appear in court by issuing a subpoena. When this occurs, the victim is legally obliged to appear. This can significantly complicate a case.

How Lack of Cooperation Can Affect the Defense

A non-cooperative alleged victim may weaken the case the prosecutor is trying to build, but it doesn’t guarantee dismissal of the case. Defense counsel may look at the other evidence available to determine whether the prosecutor can legally use it. They may investigate the strength of the evidence, whether different forms of evidence contradict each other, and whether evidence supports the claims made by the prosecution.

Protective Orders and Release Conditions

Even when an alleged victim does not want to pursue charges, a defendant must be careful about protective orders. Even if the alleged victim wants contact or reconciliation, a criminal protective order or no-contact condition may remain in effect. Breaking that, even at the alleged victim’s request, can result in further legal issues.

Facing Domestic Violence Charges? Let Our California Criminal Defense Law Firm Help You

If you’ve been accused of domestic violence, it’s time to find out how to protect your legal rights and options. Call our domestic violence defense law firm at 909-798-3300 or send us a message online to schedule a consultation.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

James Lawrence Knox is a partner at Milligan, Beswick, Levine & Knox, LLP. For almost three decades, Mr. Knox has been providing aggressive legal representation to clients facing criminal charges, as well as individuals involved in family law issues or facing administrative law proceedings. Mr. Knox, along with the other members of our legal team, is firmly committed to putting the needs of clients first and has a long and distinguished track record to show that he is a skillful litigator and knowledgeable legal professional.